Hey guys, I’ve been trying to convince my friend in the healthcare field that Phizer is not FDA approved in the US but is in Germany. She doesn’t believe me saying that the vaccines are identical. She’s a pharmacist and wants to see the ingredient list proving it is different from the one we have in the states. Does anybody know where I could see the I gradient list side by side for the difference?
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (14)
sorted by:
Use the FDA approval letter that says COMINARTY is approved and a “legally distinct” product. That is the FDA saying they are not the same thing.
Then ask your pharma friend to try and get some.
Who is Bryan Alexander and what source evidence did he present to refute that they are the same? I can say I’m Mexican and tacos are rolled soft tortillas with filling but that doesn’t mean it’s not a burrito. The FDA in their own words says they are legally distinct, meaning that the label matters in a significant way. A primary source trumps somebody’s undocumented claim any day.
https://www.nebraskamed.com/COVID/you-asked-we-answered-are-pfizers-comirnaty-and-biontech-covid-19-vaccines-the-same-or-different
I guess I’m looking for the specific ingredient which makes them not identical. But all I have is the FDA saying vaguely that they have differences. Ok, WHAT differences?
Comirnaty has two codons different from the Pfizer Experimental vaccine.
One codes for proline on the spike that makes the spike stronger, the other codes a section that helps the spike evade detection by immune sentinels — a technique of HIV — in order to amass more proteins before recognition.
If what U say is true then the cominirnaty is even more dangerous than Pfizer
I tried that. She pointed me back to a QandA on a med site from doctor Bryan Alexander stating they are the same.
it's on her to prove that it is approved, not you