The Multinational Offensive Against Free Speech Online - Free Speech is Currently Enduring a Multi-Pronged Attack, by Ryan DeLarme
(badlands.substack.com)
WE ARE THE NEWS
Comments (1)
sorted by:
... "Despite the obvious importance of these issues, I truly believe the most pressing concern facing the Western world is the multifaceted attack on free expression, particularly in the digital realm.
We’ve all probably heard the idiom that “Freedom of Speech is the First Amendment because it’s the most important”.
I never fully appreciated this sentiment, but in the past eight years—after being de-platformed and demonetized on several occasions—I've learned the hard way how truly accurate that statement is.
There are several reasons why I believe the First Amendment is the most important:
It’s the Foundation of Democracy: Freedom of speech is essential for the functioning of a democratic society. It allows for the free exchange of ideas, which is crucial for an informed electorate. Without it, citizens cannot effectively participate in the democratic process, challenge those in power, or influence public policy.
It Preserves Individual Autonomy and Dignity: This right is fundamental to individual autonomy, allowing people to express their thoughts, beliefs, and opinions. It's tied to personal dignity, as it enables individuals to define and express their identity, beliefs, and values.
Check on Government Power: Freedom of speech acts as a safeguard against tyranny and corruption by allowing criticism of government actions. It enables the press to report on abuses of power, which is vital for transparency and accountability.
Promotes Social Progress and Innovation: The free flow of information and ideas fosters innovation, scientific advancement, and social change. History shows that many societal improvements have come from individuals or groups challenging the status quo through speech.
Cultural Diversity and Exchange: It promotes cultural diversity by allowing different voices, cultures, and viewpoints to be heard. This diversity enriches society, preventing cultural stagnation and promoting mutual understanding.
Protection of Other Rights: Many other rights depend on the ability to speak freely. For instance, the right to protest, to practice religion, or to engage in political activity all hinges on the ability to express oneself without fear of reprisal.
Error Correction: In the marketplace of ideas, freedom of speech allows for the correction of errors. False or harmful ideas can be openly debated and refuted, leading to a more accurate understanding of truth.
Personal Development: Engaging with diverse viewpoints through speech can lead to personal growth, empathy, and a broader perspective on life, which is essential for individual development and societal harmony.
Legal and Philosophical Justifications: Philosophically, many argue that freedom of speech is intrinsic to human nature. Legally, it's often seen as a negative right (the right to be free from interference), which means the burden of justification falls on those who would restrict it, not on those who exercise it.
Historical Lessons: History is replete with examples where suppression of speech led to authoritarianism, misinformation, and societal harm. The lessons learned underscore the importance of protecting this right to prevent such outcomes.
Free speech is the ultimate indicator of how healthy a society and its government are, and by that metric, the entire Western world appears terminally ill." ...