Here is a Daniel's synopsis, [with my comments in square brackets]:
The discussion argues that many European leaders frame peace with Russia not as a negotiated settlement but as requiring Russia’s “deradicalization” or psychological rehabilitation—an approach likened to post-WWII treatment of Germany and Japan. The speakers call this delusional and dangerous, rooted in a moralistic “good vs. evil” worldview that masks an unwillingness to end the war.
[my comment: Germany and Japan were DEFEATED - big difference - this sort of mass-reprogramming and rehabilitation does not happen to Victors].
They contend that the West publicly claims openness to negotiations while inserting “poison pills” that ensure Russia will never agree. These include insisting on Ukraine’s borders remaining unchanged, rejecting neutrality, ignoring rights of Russian-speaking populations, and—most notably—demanding that Ukraine maintain an enormous postwar military. Ukraine and European leaders support an 800,000-strong force (funded by Europe), which would be the largest army in Europe and economically unsustainable. Russia, by contrast, has proposed far smaller numbers, closer to tens of thousands, consistent with earlier Istanbul talks.
[At Istanbul, March 2022, Ukraine had agreed, and signed, to have a 60,000 strong army - this peace-agreement will likely not allow a ten-fold increase]
The speakers argue that such proposals are deliberate sabotage designed to push the U.S., particularly President Trump, toward a European position that effectively demands Russian capitulation—something Russia has no incentive to accept given battlefield momentum in its favor.
[Good luck pushing Trump]
They emphasize a widening disconnect between Western narratives and realities on the ground, noting continued Russian advances in the east, south, and north of Ukraine, including the creation and expansion of security zones along border regions. According to this view, negotiations are gridlocked, and conflicts ultimately resolve through a “trial of strength,” which is still ongoing but increasingly favors Russia.
[LOL at the gridlock-idea. Those things are stationary. This situation is breaking out. 🎵Polyushka Polye 🎶] < That song is about finally hitting the 'meadowlands' with the cavalry, and starting the true gallop.
Finally, they warn that provocative actions—such as strikes near Russia’s strategic early-warning radar systems—are taken extremely seriously by Moscow and risk escalation. Overall, the conclusion is that Western policy is prolonging the war, not seeking peace, and that continued denial of military realities will likely lead to a decisive Russian victory rather than a negotiated settlement.
[The trick, in my opinion, is to sort the wheat from the chaff -
This is not news, we all know they want the war to continue.
Obvio didn't watch the video.
Too fucking long. They must think we have nothing better to do.
It depends
Alistair Crooke is extremely experienced, and has many internaitonal contacts, gleaned from his diplomatic service.
I take the time to listen, and found some things that were not in the news.
Yeah fair point but they could actually do it in 20 mins. They all waffle a lot and tend to repeat things and go off on tangents.
OK, so it is 'not fast enough'
Here is a Daniel's synopsis, [with my comments in square brackets]:
The discussion argues that many European leaders frame peace with Russia not as a negotiated settlement but as requiring Russia’s “deradicalization” or psychological rehabilitation—an approach likened to post-WWII treatment of Germany and Japan. The speakers call this delusional and dangerous, rooted in a moralistic “good vs. evil” worldview that masks an unwillingness to end the war.
[my comment: Germany and Japan were DEFEATED - big difference - this sort of mass-reprogramming and rehabilitation does not happen to Victors].
They contend that the West publicly claims openness to negotiations while inserting “poison pills” that ensure Russia will never agree. These include insisting on Ukraine’s borders remaining unchanged, rejecting neutrality, ignoring rights of Russian-speaking populations, and—most notably—demanding that Ukraine maintain an enormous postwar military. Ukraine and European leaders support an 800,000-strong force (funded by Europe), which would be the largest army in Europe and economically unsustainable. Russia, by contrast, has proposed far smaller numbers, closer to tens of thousands, consistent with earlier Istanbul talks.
[At Istanbul, March 2022, Ukraine had agreed, and signed, to have a 60,000 strong army - this peace-agreement will likely not allow a ten-fold increase]
The speakers argue that such proposals are deliberate sabotage designed to push the U.S., particularly President Trump, toward a European position that effectively demands Russian capitulation—something Russia has no incentive to accept given battlefield momentum in its favor.
[Good luck pushing Trump]
They emphasize a widening disconnect between Western narratives and realities on the ground, noting continued Russian advances in the east, south, and north of Ukraine, including the creation and expansion of security zones along border regions. According to this view, negotiations are gridlocked, and conflicts ultimately resolve through a “trial of strength,” which is still ongoing but increasingly favors Russia.
[LOL at the gridlock-idea. Those things are stationary. This situation is breaking out. 🎵Polyushka Polye 🎶] < That song is about finally hitting the 'meadowlands' with the cavalry, and starting the true gallop.
Finally, they warn that provocative actions—such as strikes near Russia’s strategic early-warning radar systems—are taken extremely seriously by Moscow and risk escalation. Overall, the conclusion is that Western policy is prolonging the war, not seeking peace, and that continued denial of military realities will likely lead to a decisive Russian victory rather than a negotiated settlement.
[The trick, in my opinion, is to sort the wheat from the chaff -
Pray for Trump
We all know why, but in case you don’t, ask Lindsay Graham.