Win / GreatAwakening
GreatAwakening
Sign In
DEFAULT COMMUNITIES All General AskWin Funny Technology Animals Sports Gaming DIY Health Positive Privacy
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

EDIT: Links and description cleaned up. Note that people were coming in and out halfway through during a long seven-hour day.

https://www.mapchecking.com

Map checking showing the upper bound absolute maximum of 410,000 (Extremely optimistic and unrealistic)

mapchecking.com

Map checking showing a local capacity of 200,000 (realistic lower-bound estimate)

mapchecking.com

2 years ago
3 score
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

Note that people were coming in and out halfway through during a long seven-hour day.

https://www.mapchecking.com

Map checking showing the upper bound absolute maximum of 410,000 (Extremely optimistic and unrealistic)

mapchecking.com

Map checking showing a local capacity of 200,000 (realistic lower-bound estimate)

mapchecking.com

2 years ago
3 score
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

https://www.mapchecking.com

Map checking showing the absolute maximum of 410,000 (Extremely optimistic and unrealistic)

mapchecking.com

Map checking showing a local capacity of 200,000 (realistic lower-bound estimate)

mapchecking.com

2 years ago
3 score
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

https://www.mapchecking.com

Map checking showing the absolute maximum of 410,000 (Extremely optimistic and unrealistic)

https://www.mapchecking.com/#bAACgQDY9F8JI9hBDAACAQQI_F8IR-RBDQj8Xwhn5EEMmPxfCL_kQQ20-F8Ia-RBDiz4Xwgb5EEPCPhfCC_kQQxZDF8JU9RBDTD8Xwun0EENZPhfCvfQQQxg-F8K39BBD4T0Xwqf0EEOnPRfCcPQQQzY9F8JI9BBDlT0Xwir0EEMsPhfCNfQQQ8o-F8Jj9BBDaT8XwtH0EEMuQxfCPvUQQ2tDF8JD9RBD

2 years ago
3 score
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

https://www.mapchecking.com

Map checking showing the absolute maximum (Extremely optimistic and unrealistic)

https://www.mapchecking.com/#bAACgQDY9F8JI9hBDAACAQQI_F8IR-RBDQj8Xwhn5EEMmPxfCL_kQQ20-F8Ia-RBDiz4Xwgb5EEPCPhfCC_kQQxZDF8JU9RBDTD8Xwun0EENZPhfCvfQQQxg-F8K39BBD4T0Xwqf0EEOnPRfCcPQQQzY9F8JI9BBDlT0Xwir0EEMsPhfCNfQQQ8o-F8Jj9BBDaT8XwtH0EEMuQxfCPvUQQ2tDF8JD9RBD

2 years ago
3 score
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

https://www.mapchecking.com

Map checking showing the absolute maximum (Extremely optimistic and unrealistic)

https://www.mapchecking.com/#bAACgQDY9F8JI9hBDAACAQQI_F8IR-RBDQj8Xwhn5EEMmPxfCL_kQQ20-F8Ia-RBDiz4Xwgb5EEPCPhfCC_kQQxZDF8JU9RBDTD8Xwun0EENZPhfCvfQQQxg-F8K39BBD4T0Xwqf0EEOnPRfCcPQQQzY9F8JI9BBDlT0Xwir0EEMsPhfCNfQQQ8o-F8Jj9BBDaT8XwtH0EEMuQxfCPvUQQ2tDF8JD9RBD

2 years ago
3 score
Reason: None provided.

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters that don't match aerial footage.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

https://www.mapchecking.com

https://www.mapchecking.com/#bAACgQDY9F8JI9hBDAACAQQI_F8IR-RBDQj8Xwhn5EEMmPxfCL_kQQ20-F8Ia-RBDiz4Xwgb5EEPCPhfCC_kQQxZDF8JU9RBDTD8Xwun0EENZPhfCvfQQQxg-F8K39BBD4T0Xwqf0EEOnPRfCcPQQQzY9F8JI9BBDlT0Xwir0EEMsPhfCNfQQQ8o-F8Jj9BBDaT8XwtH0EEMuQxfCPvUQQ2tDF8JD9RBD

2 years ago
1 score
Reason: Original

You're right actually, I'm doing some calculations with MapChecking.com. The maximum coverage of 80,000sqm at the maximum 5 person per sqm can't go much higher than a crowd of 400,000, and those are unrealistic parameters.

The most reasonable estimate is about 200,000 to 300,000 people, which is MASSIVE for Melbourne. I dunno how Topher Field got 450,000 but I'm hopeful it was by some other reasonable means!

https://www.mapchecking.com

https://www.mapchecking.com/#bAACgQDY9F8JI9hBDAACAQQI_F8IR-RBDQj8Xwhn5EEMmPxfCL_kQQ20-F8Ia-RBDiz4Xwgb5EEPCPhfCC_kQQxZDF8JU9RBDTD8Xwun0EENZPhfCvfQQQxg-F8K39BBD4T0Xwqf0EEOnPRfCcPQQQzY9F8JI9BBDlT0Xwir0EEMsPhfCNfQQQ8o-F8Jj9BBDaT8XwtH0EEMuQxfCPvUQQ2tDF8JD9RBD

2 years ago
1 score