He’s wrong. I and my schoolmates played “The Circle Game” in the late 1950s in the Northeast, USA. There was another rule: if the person being “signed”, could stick a finger through the loop, the game was reversed, puncher got punched and was out of the game.

He’s wrong. I and my schoolmates played “The Circle Game” in the late 1950s in the Northeast, USA. There was another rule: if the person being “signed”, could stick a finger through the loop, the game was reversed, puncher got punched and was out of the gam.