Will it be retroactive? Unlawful behaviors must not be rewarded. We had our 2nd child in France. He did not automatically have French citizenship. He would have had to serve so many years in the French military for that to occur. So maybe if DJT can’t make birthright citizenship retroactive, maybe he could impose some other form of citizenship, say provisional and outline that certain things must occur with that: no government office, decreased government benefits, etc. Thereby even though not the child’s fault where born, it still doesn’t grant full rights of citizenship and sets them apart. I know this is divisive, but something needs to be done rather than say, “Woopsy you parents broke the law, but you get a pass.”

Will it be retroactive?