I canceled my BoA account not too long ago and switched to a credit union for alumni of my school. I would highly recommend credit unions whenever possible - no/very low fees, the service is far superior, and they directly support your local community. If you join one in your area, there will also be brick-and-mortar branches for you to visit if needed.

As far as Christian communities go, I found this credit union serving members of a Protestant Christian ministry/church: https://www.mycccu.com/ It may be worth looking into, as you apparently get $200 for opening a free checking account.