this won't be a popular opinion but this law may not be the answer if we really stop to think about it. and i have because it's a complicated issue and we also need to be careful not to set up the same kompromat system that's currently in place which allows the 3 letter agencies to control so many through fear. it's unclear to me (because i didn't read bill) what will qualify as "pedo" under this law. a 20 year old dating a 16 year old in states where 17 or 18 is legal age? an 18 year old having sex with a girl that's 15 but says she lies and says 17? we can all come up with lots of unique examples. while I'm sure the are many differing opinions on all possible scenarios and what is right or wrong, life in jail, or perhaps any jail, likely isn't best corrective action in lots of these cases unless we're looking to be overrun with prisons and prisoners and really make the depraved evil creeps hide even deeper.
we all believe there are lots of pedos and worse out there and to different degrees. i do believe in reform and second chances where reform seems reasonably possible or complete leniency if it's say a 17 and 15 year old dating. i think we need to be more inviting to low level pedos and give them a chance to repent and perhaps aid them in how to get away from these evil thoughts and then perhaps have a law similar to this that is very harsh (e.g., jail for life) for 2nd offenders.
i just think that anyone looking at a life sentence for certain crimes, whatever crime that might be, is more inclined to the death and go to extremes to avoid being caught. this law could lead to kids being killed. example: some 40 year pedo is molesting a 5 year somewhere where they don't expect people around. suddenly there are people coming in the distance and carrying the kid off or silently hiding aren't an option so that the pedo can avoid JAIL FOR LIFE so the pedo in the moment decides he is going to kill the child and take his chances that way. life in prison either way likely if caught, and maybe actually less of a sentence for killing if rape can't be proven because the child is dead/mutilated
not knowing the details of the law i could be of but i do think this is a more complex problem and I'm not one to find joy in killing others
this won't be a popular opinion but this law may not be the answer if we really stop to think about it. and i have because it's a complicated issue and we also need to be careful not to set up the same kompromat system that's currently in place which allows the 3 letter agencies to control so many through fear. it's unclear to me (because i didn't read bill) what will qualify as "pedo" under this law. a 20 year old dating a 16 year old in states where 17 or 18 is legal age? an 18 year old having sex with a girl that's 15 but says she lies and says 17? we can all come up with lots of unique examples. while I'm sure the are many differing opinions on all possible scenarios and what is right or wrong, life in jail, or perhaps any jail, likely isn't best corrective action in lots of these cases unless we're looking to be overrun with prisons and prisoners and really make the depraved evil creeps hide even deeper.
we all believe there are lots of pedos and worse out there and to different degrees. i do believe in reform and second chances where reform seems reasonably possible or complete leniency if it's say a 17 and 15 year old dating. i think we need to be more inviting to low level pedos and give them a chance to repent and perhaps aid them in how to get away from these evil thoughts and then perhaps have a law similar to this that is very harsh (e.g., jail for life) for 2nd offenders.
i just think that anyone looking at a life sentence for certain crimes, whatever crime that might be, is more inclined to the death and go to extremes to avoid being caught. this law could lead to kids being killed. example: some 40 year pedo is molesting a 5 year somewhere where they don't expect people around. suddenly there are people coming in the distance and carrying the kid off or silently hiding aren't an option so that the pedo can avoid JAIL FOR LIFE so the pedo in the moment decides he is going to kill the child and take his chances that way. life in prison either way likely if caught, and maybe actually less of a sentence for killing if rape can't be proven because the child is dead/mutilated
not knowing the details of the law i could be of but i do think this is a more complex problem and I'm not one to find joy in killing others
Good thoughts... and you are correct - it depends on the letter in the law.