To be fair, I agree it looks like a complete shitpost and don't have a problem with your reasonings/logic. I just don't think the downvotes were from people who aren't able to discern or who are easy to fool but just people who didn't like the way you phrased your comment and also that you asserted it was fake and now it seems like it wasn't, which probably accrued more downvotes.

For what it's worth I upvoted you and don't think your original comment deserves any downvotes.