Sure we could’ve guessed how this one would go (though I am pleased there wasn’t even one dissenter, even though this would be blatantly unconstitutional but hey), but on other topics, as individuals, they’ve kind of been all over the place.
For example? Can you name a case in which this court has ruled differently than you would have expected from the justices’ previous opinions/dissents/concurrences? There are a few, but compared with some previous courts this one has been a model of consistency.
I get what you’re saying, but again, I don’t mean the rulings of the court as a whole, just individual Justice’s opinions. The random general Leftist having a “right” opinion or a Conservative “siding with the left.”
I think all the rulings as a Court have been consistent with what you would expect. I haven’t been surprised.
Really you’re right, and I think I’ve seen some more actual Constituional opinions recently than recently and previously.
I’ve just been mildly surprised a couple times on some individual opinions, but then again I’m only familiar with the history of about half of them.
Also how I interpreted that.
Sure we could’ve guessed how this one would go (though I am pleased there wasn’t even one dissenter, even though this would be blatantly unconstitutional but hey), but on other topics, as individuals, they’ve kind of been all over the place.
For example? Can you name a case in which this court has ruled differently than you would have expected from the justices’ previous opinions/dissents/concurrences? There are a few, but compared with some previous courts this one has been a model of consistency.
I get what you’re saying, but again, I don’t mean the rulings of the court as a whole, just individual Justice’s opinions. The random general Leftist having a “right” opinion or a Conservative “siding with the left.”
I think all the rulings as a Court have been consistent with what you would expect. I haven’t been surprised.
Really you’re right, and I think I’ve seen some more actual Constituional opinions recently than recently and previously.
I’ve just been mildly surprised a couple times on some individual opinions, but then again I’m only familiar with the history of about half of them.