That comment doesn't seem to question the data, just the conclusions made from it.
My quick scan of the data in the linked documents indicates a mixed outcome. But I didn't read the reports in their entirety (in the links). I suppose I should have spent more time scanning the reports to verify the trends in the article.
One thing I did notice is that the data changes over time, and it seems to be trending in the wrong direction to support the conclusions of the last report, which suggests the vaccines are preventing infections and covid mortality. The conclusion is correct insofar as the data presented (within the specified time frame), but the trends are important.
That comment doesn't seem to question the data, just the conclusions made from it.
My quick scan of the data in the linked documents indicates a mixed outcome. But I didn't read the reports in their entirety (in the links). I suppose I should have spent more time scanning the reports to verify the trends in the article.
One thing I did notice is that the data changes over time, and it seems to be trending in the wrong direction to support the conclusions of the last report, which suggests the vaccines are preventing infections and covid mortality. The conclusion is correct insofar as the data presented (within the specified time frame), but the trends are important.