Let's just say for the sake of argument that we did form another republic. Now let point this out: The enemy would still be alive and well and they would do everything in their power to disrupt our "New Republic". From pumping a stream of constant propaganda to financing insurrections. These ppl won't stop till every trance of them is wiped out. This is why your ideal is not only bad but, suicidal. I, myself will never give up on our republic because once we do, we and our republic will die.