Somehow I don't think any of this happened by accident. This was intentional. Just my two-cents.
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (13)
sorted by:
I'm inclined to think it happened. I've looked into the theories that it was faked in some way, and so far, the evidence has all fallen apart when I looked deeper, because it's cherry-picked and ignores other evidence. For example, the supposed discrepancies regarding how long it would take to cremate so many bodies fall apart when you read the records from concentration camps detailing their cremation process (which was drastically different from normal cremation processes and speeded up the process many times over). Similarly, the arguments that there weren't any gas chambers, that Auschwitz wasn't so bad because it had swimming pools, etc, are based on cherry-picked information and fall apart when one looks deeper (for instance, Auschwitz wasn't one camp but a collection of smaller camps, not all of which were for housing Jewish prisoners; the section for Jews was called Birkenau and there were no swimming pools located there).
I'm not sure Stalin was Jewish. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (arguably the greatest historian of Soviet communism) didn't seem to think so. He wrote a book called "200 Years Together" detailing the history of Jews in Russia, including their role in the Bolshevik revolution. The book is banned in many places and hard to find, especially in its uncensored form. Here's a link to an uncensored PDF of it:
https://web.archive.org/web/20221129195455if_/https://fs12n1.sendspace.com/dl/630c95ca41b11b90630229444756d027/6386634f30e8f7e0/10xc7v/Two Hundred Years Together - Aleksandr Isayevich Solzhenitsyn.pdf
There's a popular fake Solzhenitsyn quote that often makes the rounds. It goes like this:
However, it has never been sourced back to anything that Solzhenitsyn is documented to have written. In chapter 15 of "200 Years Together", he criticized attempts to absolve Russians of all blame for the October Revolution and to put the blame solely on Jews. In fact, the "you must understand..." quote reads an awful lot like someone took some of his words from the portion of chapter 15 quoted below and twisted his words to mean the opposite of what he intended:
In chapter 14, he wrote this:
The book is very thorough and nuanced, neither downplaying nor exaggerating the role of Jews in the Bolshevik Revolution. Solzhenitsyn carefully addressed every aspect and angle.