They recused themselves because they were named defendants, so the recusal was absolutely required - this isn’t a “recuse because you might be biased”, the rule against judges hearing cases in which they are defendants or plaintiffs is ironclad.
And there is no “if this does make its way to the court here”. It already did, and the court denied cert. That is the final decision.
They recused themselves because they were named defendants, so the recusal was absolutely required - this isn’t a “recuse because you might be biased”, the rule against judges hearing cases in which they are defendants or plaintiffs is ironclad. And there is no “if this does make its way to the court here”. It already did, and the court denied cert. That is the final decision.