This was slightly derogatory, but only slightly. The rest was was a legitimate point that you ignored in your response.
You special -- "Hey yuze guyz this isn't the same as the chans, so don't chan here."
Meh. I wouldn't take offense at this, but that's just me. It still contains within it a legitimate point.
So he's purporting to educate newer users about terminology. But this acutally isn't correct terminology, the way we use it. This is not our culture. If you are on T_D/TDW/PW, we don't have breads, we don't refer to our threads or posts as breads.
There are similarities in how we do things however, and there are similarities in the actions of alienjesus to shitting in the bread. It may not have been perfectly accurate, but it didn't need to be, and frankly, there is no reason to not carry over the analogy or terminology here imo since the actions and context are similar enough. I am not suggesting you should agree with that assessment, or with the person we are talking about, I am only saying you didn't address it and rather tried to suggest it was wrong to even talk about it in that way.
One is as a way of saying there is no reason to come out th'gate as a prick on a fellow poster
From an outside perspective, I saw so little "prickery" going on, that I thought your response was unwarranted and way over the top.
without knowing if youre talking to
This is irrelevant, which is why using credentials for a discussion is always the wrong play.
Argument is used to get to the truth. It is only through earnest discourse that we can even come close to achieving that lofty goal. Using appeals to authority, strawmen arguments, ignoring the points, implied or explicit of some argument, or all of the other argumentative techniques that are divorced from logos never help achieve a step closer to the truth. At best they only help one side come out victorious at the expense of the truth.
I try very hard to not use my credentials in arguments. If I can't make my argument stand on its own then my years of experience or education on some topic are irrelevant. I do this not because I don't want to. Sometimes I just want to nip ridiculous shit in the bud. I do it this way because this isn't about me. This is about saving the world from the Luciferians, and the only way we can win is by exploring the truth together.
"The truth will set us free". It's not just a meme.
This was slightly derogatory, but only slightly. The rest was was a legitimate point that you ignored in your response.
Meh. I wouldn't take offense at this, but that's just me. It still contains within it a legitimate point.
There are similarities in how we do things however, and there are similarities in the actions of alienjesus to shitting in the bread. It may not have been perfectly accurate, but it didn't need to be, and frankly, there is no reason to not carry over the analogy or terminology here imo since the actions and context are similar enough. I am not suggesting you should agree with that assessment, or with the person we are talking about, I am only saying you didn't address it and rather tried to suggest it was wrong to even talk about it in that way.
From an outside perspective, I saw so little "prickery" going on, that I thought your response was unwarranted and way over the top.
This is irrelevant, which is why using credentials for a discussion is always the wrong play.
Argument is used to get to the truth. It is only through earnest discourse that we can even come close to achieving that lofty goal. Using appeals to authority, strawmen arguments, ignoring the points, implied or explicit of some argument, or all of the other argumentative techniques that are divorced from logos never help achieve a step closer to the truth. At best they only help one side come out victorious at the expense of the truth.
I try very hard to not use my credentials in arguments. If I can't make my argument stand on its own then my years of experience or education on some topic are irrelevant. I do this not because I don't want to. Sometimes I just want to nip ridiculous shit in the bud. I do it this way because this isn't about me. This is about saving the world from the Luciferians, and the only way we can win is by exploring the truth together.
"The truth will set us free". It's not just a meme.