Questions about Jesus.
✝️ Scripture 🕊️
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (24)
sorted by:
"perpetual virginity of Mary"? She had children by Joseph after Jesus was born.
That's debatable. There was no word for cousin at the time in the Greek language.
https://www.bible-researcher.com/adelphos.html
"Brother" and "Sister" could have been as open ended as anyone from his home village, according to some interpretations.
But Matthew 1:25 with "But he knew her not, till she had brought forth her first born son," does open the door that they were permitted to have relations, but not that they necessarily did.
I don't care either way, personally, so long as it's not in question that Joseph didn't touch her at all during pregnancy. If he did, I see no logical way to say Jesus was born of a virgin then.
James was a son of Mary and Joseph and therefore a half-brother to Jesus and brother to Joseph, Simon, Judas, and their sisters (Matthew 13:55).
Other translations use brethren.
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew+13:55&version=GNV
In full context, they weren't calling into question his heritage, they knew it quite well, but rather they were calling into question his claims of being the Messiah. He did not fit the prophecy, because they were aware he was not "Of the House of David" in terms of being related to the royal family as they were expecting from the Messiah.
They were more upset that he was just some scrub carpenter's son and not a son of a king. They further were upset that a carpenter's son would have such deep understanding of scripture when they said "Whence cometh this wisdom and great works unto this man?"
They wanted to know who taught him all he knew, and refused to believe a nobody would dare speak with such authority.
I'm not saying you're wrong in him having siblings of Mary, but in context they used his perceived siblings to reject him as the Messiah. He didn't fit their preconceived notions.