Real. I've seen this firsthand. Northern Indiana has huge Amish communities. 99.9% of the time they don't talk or involve themselves in politics as it is already obvious to them. This picture represents decades of repressed discourse finally surfacing.

If you really want a good picture, go to a gun show and look at the Amish there. When you see a newly married 20 year old and he's got 4 rifles in his arms, including an ar15, and he's paying cash, you kinda get the picture of where they are at.