@Grok: "The CIA analyst referenced in the reporting (by Michael Shellenberger and others) is Eric Ciaramella. He was a CIA officer detailed to the NSC under Obama who stayed into the Trump administration and filed the 2019 whistleblower complaint that sparked the first impeachment. That complaint cited an OCCRP investigation (which received USAID grants) on Giuliani's Ukraine ties. Critics call it journalism; supporters of the claims see deeper coordination."
Eric CIArmella was also involved in the fabrication of the ICA used in the Russia, Russia hoax.
@Grok: "The CIA analyst referenced in the reporting (by Michael Shellenberger and others) is Eric Ciaramella. He was a CIA officer detailed to the NSC under Obama who stayed into the Trump administration and filed the 2019 whistleblower complaint that sparked the first impeachment. That complaint cited an OCCRP investigation (which received USAID grants) on Giuliani's Ukraine ties. Critics call it journalism; supporters of the claims see deeper coordination."
Eric CIArmella was also involved in the fabrication of the ICA used in the Russia, Russia hoax.
Under orders. No way they operated independently.