posted ago by bgny ago by bgny +508 / -0

Some highlights from Dr. Shiva (Full report):

  • images of ballot envelopes with an approval stamp behind the basic graphics of the envelope, suggesting tampering
  • Heat map showing signature legibility percentage flipped from 95% legible and 5% illegible four weeks before the election to an inverse relationship of 5% legible and 95% illegible four days after the election
  • 34,448 duplicates from 17126 voters. County reported 0
  • 25% surge in duplicates from November 4th to November 9th
  • 1,919 blank signatures stamped as approved. County Reported 1,455
  • 587 bad signatures. County reported 0
  • 934 late returns. County Reported 0
  • 2580 scribbles. County reported 0

Some highlights from Doug Logan, CEO of CyberNinjas(Full reports):

  • 9,041 more mail ballots returned and recorded than the official number sent.
  • 3,432 more ballots cast than the list of people who show as having cast a vote
  • 23,344 people voted via mail in ballot even though they showed as having moved and no one with that last name shows as living at that address.
  • 2,600 excess duplicate ballots.
  • 2,382 people voted in person after having moved out of the county.
  • 5,047 voted in more than one county for up to 5,295 votes.
  • At least one batch of 50 ballots were tabulated twice.
  • 255,326 Early Votes show in the VM55 that do not have a corresponding EV33 entry.
  • 282 votes from deceased.
  • 393 with incomplete names.
  • 2861 voters have shared an AFFSEQ number with another voter.

Some highlights from Ben Cotton, CEO of CyFIR (Full report):

  • Federal law requires election data to be preserved for 22 months following an election. "Maricopa County failed to preserve the operating system security logs" within the required timeframe.
  • The system had 2 bootable drives, which is not an approved configuration.
  • More than 85,000 files were deleted between October 28 and November 5th, 2020 and more than 1 million files were deleted between November 1st 2020 and March 16th 2021.
  • A script was run multiple times to intentionally overwrite the security logs, including the day before the auditors received the system. They have the screenshots of the people who were at the machines at the times the machines were tampered with.
  • Maricopa County's system had a single password for all users and administrators. The password was created on system initialization and was never changed.
  • There were hundreds of anonymous logins including remote logins.
  • Remote Access, Terminal Services, and IPV6 were enabled on the EMS server. 59 ports open on boot with high port listening activity. Connectivity to the internet has been established, in violation of Arizona law and contrary to what we have been told about the system.
  • The County's auditors claimed they found no internet history, but CyFIR found significant internet history in unallocated disc space.
  • One EMS system connection to the internet happened on February 1, 2021, which coincides with the beginning of the audit and a purge of thousands of files.


  • numerous state laws were not followed.
  • chain of custody was not accurately kept, making it impossible who touched what and when.
  • obstruction occurred to prevent a full audit.
  • it was impossible to certify the election.

All audit reports.

Karen Fann's letter to AG Brnovich

Senator Kelly Townsend calls for the election to be nullified and for us to move forward with indictments.

41 Legislators from Multiple States Write a Letter to the American People Calling for a 50-State Audit, Decertification Where Appropriate, and Possible Convening of the US House of Representatives

Comments (45)
sorted by:
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Insignificant 14 points ago +14 / -0

Excellent summary! Don't forget the best part though. They still haven't looked at the routers/passwords/splunk logs, etc. Nearly everyone that spoke today said they couldn't complete their work without these essentials. They also said they had reached an agreement to finally get their hands on all of it though. Just as Mike Lindell said at his cyber-symposium, the results shown thus far do not include the cyber-manipulation of votes.

Dr. Shiva showed us 34K duplicates from 17k unique voters (were they Trump or Biden votes?), and Doug Logan showed us 23K mail-in ballots that voted from a prior address (39.5% for Dems/33% for Republicans). Is it enough to decertify? Probably, but we still need to see the rest.

WhoBuiltTheCagesJOOO 2 points ago +2 / -0

Or physical paper. That’s a big one people are forgetting.

TrumpTrain_531 2 points ago +2 / -0

Remember when they said that the machines weren't connected to the internet? And then Ben Cotton showed us that they were?

Pepperidge Farm remembers

Insignificant 2 points ago +2 / -0

Yes I love how he kept saying that he couldn't say for sure that votes were flipped without getting his hands on the routers, etc. BUT he did show that internet connectivity was possible and likely. And that's enough to warrant a further investigation since they've been telling the audit people over and over that it was impossible to connect to the internet. This is just getting started.

skf93 2 points ago +2 / -0

Did they say when they would reveal what they find on the routers and spunk logs?

Insignificant 1 point ago +1 / -0

I don't think they did. I just heard them several times saying they had reached an agreement with the county so they could finally get what they requested. I'd expect that this will take a lot longer than we want, but it's happening. The announcement yesterday really was the first major step by announcing publicly.