Dan Scavino. Marker 9 comms!
(media.greatawakening.win)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (115)
sorted by:
Wouldn't "I love cats and dogs etc." restrict the meaning of etc. to the dog? Which doesn't make much sense either.
Why would the addition of the words "etc." or "and so on" at the end of a list restrict the meaning of those words to the final item? I'm not familiar with that idea.
/wordnerd
I wondered just how "etcetera" is defined as a part of speech. Apparently few others have thought of that, because I got plenty of examples of usage and only Merriam Webster says it is a noun. However, it isn't just a noun, it is a placeholder in a list of similar nouns, to be used like an ellipsis (....) for something missing. The list needs to have items that go together, conceptually. If you say "dogs, cats, etc.," the implication is domestic animals, or pets. If you say "the cat and dog etc.," then the "etc." is implying a missing list of--what? More dogs? Dog toys? Now if "etc." can be called a modifier, then it refers to "dog" which is the nearest prior noun, i.e. the "antecedent." Getting antecedents wrong (lost antecedent) can totally change the meaning in a sentence and paragraph, and is probably my pet grammar gripe. (Insert picture of lost and confused Auntie Sedent doing Mr. Magoo-like things) Anyway, in the paucity of information about this universal shortcut, I did find that it must always be preceded with a comma.
But why
No comma needed when writing out "and so on"
Silly, isn't it