Yes. They are criminals at CA Franchise Tax Board. Use their own rules against them and ask why they are "fabricating tax claims and then incentivizing employees to collect on fabricated tax claims". <---Most hated question by all state Tax agencies. Force them to show the sauce on the tax claim, and just keep saying they are fabricating it.
If you get a copy of their "Rules and Procedures" you can point out specific violations of their own processes which they intentionally do not follow, invalidating almost all FTB actions, automatically.
I am not disputing them over how much they believe I owe... I am going after the lowest hanging fruit, the areas where no one will doubt their actions are bona fide criminal behavior.
In my case, FTB straight out embezzled my quarterly estimated tax payments. I sent them canceled checks 31 times... couldn't find the $... then demanded that I send them more money to cover our tax liability... I sent them the extra money they demanded to stop the harassment... they embezzled that money, too, and then filed a wage garnishment...
Anyway, the more I digging I did, the more full on accounting fraud has come out. I've got 8 documented schemes to charge taxpayers more than what the FTB assesses is owed, using their own records that they submitted in court as evidence: https://gwsandiego.net/blog/?p=611
Furthermore, they are systematically violating taxpayer rights to file disputes and to see your own records (so you can't see the accounting fraud).
At this point, because of the egregious accounting irregularities, I am fairly certain that the "suspended" (embezzled) funds are going into some kind of off-the-books spending account. The FTB said that since my request for information was so large, they needed until February 28, 2023 to respond. We'll see what they say... probably their typical evasive word salad that doesn't actually disclose any information.
This is going to bake your noodle: CA FTB appears to be a privately owned corporation. If you file a FOIA for their articles of incorporation to get the sauce, you can request a permanent injunction to terminate their operation with the boundaries of California State (Union State, 1850) per violation of Article IV, Section 4 of Constitution (if you sue them in Federal District Court).
If you saw the last message, then disregard it. My jaw had dropped and it took me a couple of minutes to fully process what you have written. I am writing up a California Public Records Request right now! I am going to send you a PM, too.
CA Tax Board needs to be dissolved via challenge to the consitutionality of the law that was used to create it. I believe I have an approach that can be used in other states as well. I will put together a post titled "Guide to Dissolving your State Tax Board for the cost of a $402 Federal District Court lawsuit". I believe it should work for all states with an "integrated" STATE BAR CORP that has been unconstitutionally inserted into the state gov't (Judiciary Branch) in violation of Article IV, Section 4.
Doing this so other anons can try it in their states as well.
Yes. They are criminals at CA Franchise Tax Board. Use their own rules against them and ask why they are "fabricating tax claims and then incentivizing employees to collect on fabricated tax claims". <---Most hated question by all state Tax agencies. Force them to show the sauce on the tax claim, and just keep saying they are fabricating it.
If you get a copy of their "Rules and Procedures" you can point out specific violations of their own processes which they intentionally do not follow, invalidating almost all FTB actions, automatically.
I am not disputing them over how much they believe I owe... I am going after the lowest hanging fruit, the areas where no one will doubt their actions are bona fide criminal behavior.
In my case, FTB straight out embezzled my quarterly estimated tax payments. I sent them canceled checks 31 times... couldn't find the $... then demanded that I send them more money to cover our tax liability... I sent them the extra money they demanded to stop the harassment... they embezzled that money, too, and then filed a wage garnishment...
Anyway, the more I digging I did, the more full on accounting fraud has come out. I've got 8 documented schemes to charge taxpayers more than what the FTB assesses is owed, using their own records that they submitted in court as evidence: https://gwsandiego.net/blog/?p=611
Plus, there are several more suspected schemes that I am working on getting info for now: https://gwsandiego.net/blog/?p=1191
Furthermore, they are systematically violating taxpayer rights to file disputes and to see your own records (so you can't see the accounting fraud).
At this point, because of the egregious accounting irregularities, I am fairly certain that the "suspended" (embezzled) funds are going into some kind of off-the-books spending account. The FTB said that since my request for information was so large, they needed until February 28, 2023 to respond. We'll see what they say... probably their typical evasive word salad that doesn't actually disclose any information.
This is going to bake your noodle: CA FTB appears to be a privately owned corporation. If you file a FOIA for their articles of incorporation to get the sauce, you can request a permanent injunction to terminate their operation with the boundaries of California State (Union State, 1850) per violation of Article IV, Section 4 of Constitution (if you sue them in Federal District Court).
If you saw the last message, then disregard it. My jaw had dropped and it took me a couple of minutes to fully process what you have written. I am writing up a California Public Records Request right now! I am going to send you a PM, too.
And it gets better...Corporations have no immunity from Constitutional violations per Hale v Henkel 201 US 43 (1906)
CA Tax Board needs to be dissolved via challenge to the consitutionality of the law that was used to create it. I believe I have an approach that can be used in other states as well. I will put together a post titled "Guide to Dissolving your State Tax Board for the cost of a $402 Federal District Court lawsuit". I believe it should work for all states with an "integrated" STATE BAR CORP that has been unconstitutionally inserted into the state gov't (Judiciary Branch) in violation of Article IV, Section 4.
Doing this so other anons can try it in their states as well.