By and large, this community is CONSERVATIVE and upholds conservative values and policies. I would like to challenge our thinking when it comes to Universal School Choice.
Let’s start by establishing our philosophy on government. Most of us, if not all of us would agree that states’ rights have been sacrificed at the altar of the federal government which has become a behemoth that was never intended by the founders of this country. I think it’s fair to say that we are OPPOSED to the concepts instituted through the New Deal such as socialized income offered through the SSA or the socialized healthcare system born out of SSA referred to as Medicare/Medicaid. Likewise, we are OPPOSED to any sort of proposed universal basic income or any legislation which is passed that dictates participation in any of these programs mentioned.
Yet, when it comes to education, we, CONSERVATIVES, are suddenly PRO government spending on educational programming, up to and including the government funding of private education or home education through Universal School Choice programs.
PUBLIC SCHOOLS are not conservative. PUBLIC FUNDING of private schools is not conservative. PUBLIC FUNDING of homeschools is not conservative. Any school/homeschool which takes government money is/will be expected to adhere to government standards for education and agendas.
Universal School Choice is equal to universal basic income or any other socialist policy which seeks to control programming through funding. It is NOT a conservative ideal.
I understand that the money offered to homeschoolers looks enticing for those of you who are receiving those funds. But you are in bed with the government just the same. I understand that by accepting vouchers, your private school can offer more options for classes. But you are in bed with the government just the same. You will be held to government standards for operation of those schools because you are running those schools on government funds.
Does this mean that I am on the side of the teachers’ unions? In this case, YES, I am. Teachers unions don’t want School Choice because it drains money from the government schools. I don’t want Universal School Choice because it turns any school it touches into a public school. I can live with siding with them for the sake of protecting my homeschool. My children and our family’s values are the top priority in this issue.
I am a home educator of 15 years; I am very involved in my local community through various boards, homeschool groups, etc. I am connected to our state’s legislative watchdog for all things home education. I pay my dues to HSLDA. Please heed my warnings and meet my challenge to change your thinking on this issue.
Universal School Choice is not a conservative ideal; it is a Trojan horse, and conservatives should be OPPOSED to Universal School Choice.
Can't go along with this. Everyone in society benefits from well educated citizens. We have to carefully watch our tendency in this area to want to enjoy the public benefit while privatizing the losses. I'm not saying a purely optional, private only education system can't work in a society. Only that it's sub optimal.
Obviously, the public arena is ripe for abuse. We've watched that happen in real time. But that doesn't mean we can't stop the abuse and still keep alive the opportunity. The last thing I want is to watch children suffer because their parents prioritized paying off their credit card debt at the expense of their kids.
The trick is to make universal education responsive to the parents. So, in your example, that everything the public money touches isn't under central government control. The closer you get to communities, the more it matches local values and the less intrusive administration becomes. So assuming there are sufficiently diverse schools, and homeschooling is still an option for those who can't find a community, Universal School Choice seems to me as the best way to accomplish that.
You can certainly have it your way, and government will gladly fund your school choice, but presenting this program as anything other than a socialist ideal is disingenuous. And believing that the government is benevolent in its attempts to get its talons into every realm of education is naive.
I will continue to deny the government access to my school for as long as I am able.