Holy Trojan Horse, Batman!
(media.greatawakening.win)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (22)
sorted by:
I agree with your statement that government funding leads to government control. Public schools are a testament to this. But school choice, as expressed in Trump's Agenda 47, is a move to transfer control of existing schools away from government in favor of families. As things stand today, how is that a bad move?
I see this as a smart move to get away from where we are today, destroying the influence of teachers' unions and education system bureaucrats. You don't need to agree, but I think you're demonizing a good solution because you want a perfect one instead.
In fact, there's a lot to be said for public commitment to education: homeschooling rarely produces a well-tooled machine shop, science labs, or large swimming pools. Removing all government funding from one day to the next would create a lot of chaos, and an incremental approach to change is not horrible. And unless you want centrally controlled schools, which you clearly don't, allowing parents to direct the funds instead of bureaucrats will ensure that the good parts don't get thrown away. I still think it's a good step.
Allow me to clarify my point. I'm not opposed to the existence of government-funded schools. In fact, I believe they are necessary. It will be a glorious day when they are brought back to the state level and the DOE is dismantled, however.
My opposition is to the encroachment of the government into the private and homeschool sectors. Allowing this money to trickle in will eventually make those schools vulnerable to larger governmental control. It's a Trojan horse. Those of us who have opted out of the government system are watching with trepidation as newcomers to the private and homeschooling worlds bring the government with them.
And the government knows EXACTLY what they are doing.
Fair enough. Trump's plan, as stated in his agenda, involves closing the DOE and sending the money direct to states and guaranteeing it can be directed by parents who choose to do it.
That will still be vulnerable to state and city unions who loathe losing control and will work to claw it back. Their efforts should be fought against with every tooth and nail.
This has been happening repeatedly in many parts. I've seen it in L.A. County as charter schools are approved under law and certificates granted after agencies are obligated by lawsuits to do so, and then later decertified by administrative BS led by teacher union admins (not even the teachers themselves) and public school admin bureaucrats who want to claw back the funding and indoctrination power. It's definitely a war. But the more power the parents have, the better. If diverting DS resources to do it is possible, I'm all for it.
But in the end, a public commitment to an educated populace is a good thing. Public pooled resources are useful to accomplish that. But centrally controlling it is a big no-no.
For now, Trump is not in office, and his plan is not in effect. Our efforts must reflect our reality if they are to have any positive outcomes in the here-and-now. Vouchers, ESAs, and School Choice are DANGEROUS to homeschoolers. Private schools are in danger, too, for what it's worth.
I'm actually wondering what the legal definition of homeschool is state by state. Our state refers to it as "a non-accredited private school with less than one employee." How will this definition help or hurt us when and if education (rightfully) returns to the states? How else can we shore up the private and homeschool arenas so that they are immune to potential governmental controls?
Have you read The 1776 Report? I printed and bound that beauty the day of its release. https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/The-Presidents-Advisory-1776-Commission-Final-Report.pdf
I just pray that man gets into office. I don't agree with him on everything, obviously, but our freedoms were never more secure than with him in charge.
Yeah, that's a great document.
Ron Paul has a number of published positions on homeschooling, one of my favorite was when he said that "all these homeschooling programs emphasize that they teach according to government standards, but the whole point of homeschooling is to have your own standards."
I don't think you and I will agree. I think vouchers are a good way to wrest power away from the current corrupt structure while saving much of the infrastructure and of the good people inside the awful system. You think it's a Trojan horse. But it's only a Trojan horse when the bad people are pushing it. You might be right at a local level, but from what I've seen the bad people are lining up against it on a federal level.
I see it kind of like a fire department or a prison system. Both of those have ingrained unions that routinely hold the taxpayers hostage to their demands, with corrupt politicians happily giving away money that only their (supposed) constituents are liable for. Ending the corruption is necessary, but ending either department has serious consequences that are best avoided if you can do it. Obviously it's not a perfect parallel, but as far as it goes, I think school choice is a great step at the federal level.
WWG1WGA, fren.