Ok...read this carefully...IT DOESN'T MATTER THAT SHE WAS BORN ON US SOIL! She is NOT a Natural Born Citizen because her parents are NOT SOLELY US CITIZENS! Read Chapter 19 Paragraph two of The Law of Nations (Emer de Vattel). By definition a Natural Born Citizen is the child of parents who are solely US Citizens. Now in that paragraph Emer uses the phrase, "parents who are citizens." But he didn't mean that Natural Born Citizen meant the child of parents who held dual citizenship. There was no such thing as dual citizenship in the United States at that time. So the Framers of the Constitution understood this to mean EXACTLY what it says...only "parents who are citizens."

This has to do with loyalty to country. The Framers knew that a man who sought the highest office of the nation had to be firmly imbued with a loyalty for our nation. In their wisdom, the greatest protector of this loyalty was being raised by parents who were demonstrably committed and solely loyal to the United States. If a child's parents were not loyal enough Americans to seek, have and hold American Citizenship...and American Citizenship ONLY, then there was a chance the child might end up with dual loyalties like their parents. The Framers were well versed in Scripture and they believed in the wisdom of God's Word that says, "Train up a child in the way he should go: and when he is old, he will not depart from it..." So, with this in mind, the Framers hearkened to the wise advice found in The Law of Nations regarding being a Natural Born Citizen as a way to avoid us having to deal with men of low character like the Gay Kenyan who would have "other" loyalties because they were not raised by God fearing, America loving Patriotic parents who had only loyalty to America...