Win / GreatAwakening
GreatAwakening
Communities Topics Log In Sign Up
Sign In
Hot
All Posts
Settings
All
Profile
Saved
Upvoted
Hidden
Messages

Your Communities

General
AskWin
Funny
Technology
Animals
Sports
Gaming
DIY
Health
Positive
Privacy
News
Changelogs

More Communities

frenworld
OhTwitter
MillionDollarExtreme
NoNewNormal
Ladies
Conspiracies
GreatAwakening
IP2Always
GameDev
ParallelSociety
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Content Policy
DEFAULT COMMUNITIES • All General AskWin Funny Technology Animals Sports Gaming DIY Health Positive Privacy
GreatAwakening Where We Go Qne, We Go All!
hot new rising top

Sign In or Create an Account

28
Critiques to Consider against Proposed Solutions in Poso's new book Unhumans: (1) Let the System Fail Under its Own Weight, (2) Install a "Benevolent" Dictator (twitter.com)
posted 1 year ago by smartbaum 1 year ago by smartbaum +28 / -0
7 comments share
7 comments share save hide report block hide replies
Comments (7)
sorted by:
▲ 5 ▼
– smartbaum [S] 5 points 1 year ago +5 / -0

I think this point in particular needs to be mulled over:

This is also how the concept of "let it eat itself," or collapse under its own weight, should be viewed: a failure of strategy. This Leviathan will continue to stack failing ideas on top of each other by externalizing the consequences and devouring more and more resources until it runs out, at which point it will necessarily collapse, and that collapse would kill billions and splinter America, and the west, into Medieval fiefdoms of warlords and terror. We should probably rule that out as an acceptable path.

I am fully open to the possibility that the so called Dissident Right has its own psyop to push for this sort of dystopian vision of inevitable societal collapse, from which to rebuild something post-repubic. It's just that they frame it entirely differently than say the WEF compatbile globalists, because they are two completely different audiences.

The dialectic at work (and this is not just Dissident Right celebrities populating alt media, but also theocratic voices in the Christian Nationalism movement) is pushing for this dilemma of some necessary extreme as the only antidote to the current situation of extreme government corruption. And of course the Dissident Rights like in Poso's world also propose some benevolent strongman, a semi-dictator, just as the Christian Nationalists advocate an end point of some "Christian Caesar" type. Yes they use that exact terminology. Caesar, who we can all recall heralded the end of the Roman republic and the beginning of Empire, with a centralized authority figure based on hereditary and spiritual qualifications. The same of which in principle the Founding Fathers specifically rejected in European models.

So take all that for what it's worth.

permalink save report block reply
▲ 2 ▼
– winn 2 points 1 year ago +2 / -0

Man. This is a tippy-top comment and post.

Thank you for this. I'd updoot it 1,000 times if I could.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 1 ▼
– Plebbitimmigrant 1 point 1 year ago +1 / -0

I mean part of the problem. Is most people’s experience with the ideals as proposed by the Founders.

Is either the current mess we call a World and Federal Government today. Or people waxing poetically online about a system and way of life no one in living memory has lived under.

Or arguments and cherry-picked quotes taken out of context online. To justify whatever inane point or juvenile insult someone is hurling at whoever they are arguing with.

Wouldn’t be particularly shocking more and more people would be looking elsewhere other than the ideals of the founders to fix current days problems.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 2 ▼
– Plebbitimmigrant 2 points 1 year ago +2 / -0

I mean. Many historical Republics usually included the option of installing a Dictator to deal with emergency.

In fact we borrow the term “Dictator” from the Roman Republic.

The Caveat being their power was normally limited to taking whatever steps they deemed necessary to address whatever emergency dictated they be given such powers. So while broad and far reaching. It wasn’t total. And the option to force them from Office remained.

So much of what we take for granted politically. And the political philosophy that ultimately has become the primary focus today on both sides of the aisle. Even in some of the alternative spheres. Is ultimately the result of the post WW2 era economic and educational system. Which comparatively speaking was a time of relatively unrivaled prosperity, For the U.S at least. And enforced by the U.S Hegemony. With many people taking aspects of it for granted in their philosophy. That system is breaking down. In frankly a rather spectacular fashion.

And we happen to have got a distinct lack of Washington’s, Jefferson’s, Adam’s, Monroe’s, and other figures of yore running around to lead the Republic. The Closest thing we do have is Trump. The times ahead will undoubtedly be interesting ones.

permalink save report block reply
▲ 2 ▼
– smartbaum [S] 2 points 1 year ago +2 / -0

Yes. We get the distinct impression that Washington was one of a kind individual even among a generation of one of a kinds. His even handedness, measured temper and wisdom under fire, working truly from a heart aching fir the best possible way forward for the new nation, is awe inspiring. He was a unifier in the best sense of that idea. It is not entirely clear to me how that could work out today.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 1 ▼
– Plebbitimmigrant 1 point 1 year ago +1 / -0

Frankly it probably wouldn’t unless it was the Prince of Peace himself who would come down from on high.

Anyone else might be able to buy time with compromise and appeals to patriotism. But that’s all it would be. Buying time.

Before the reality of the political situation, the divided nature of modern politics, and frankly the retarded political ideologies on both sides of the aisle that have firmly taken root. Ultimately come roaring back to the fore and can’t be pushed back.

A couple small Preliminary polls suggest. Primarily among the Youth and Young Adults. Support for Democratic and Republican processes, the forms of government not the American parties, is down across the board. With many having a warming reception to more authoritarian ideas and policies. Including empowering the executive to ignore the Courts and Congress at will. While they were small polls so take it a grain of salt.

If they are anyway indicative of larger trends. As has sometimes been the case before. Where small polls were indicative of societal shifts before mainstream society and polling even caught on. We have some problems that eliminating the Cabal won’t immediately solve or provide a solution to.

Though being brutally honest. Outside of the initial shock of a change. I doubt most of the Country is that attached to Republicanism, that they would ultimately truly care whether whoever was sitting their ass in the Oval Office was a King, Emperor, or Generalissimo or some other flavor of authoritarian. Provided they and their heirs respected the Bill of Rights and kept Taxes low to non-existent.

permalink parent save report block reply
▲ 1 ▼
– winn 1 point 1 year ago +1 / -0

Oooh Oooh! Is this the part where MAGA is duped into requesting a return to a theocratic-dictatorship???!! I love this part! Yes, we need a benevolent dictator! Yes! I vote for Archbishop Vigano! Let him become king of the world! We should just discard the form of government given to us by God via the hands of our founding fathers, because obviously it doesn't work since the country has fallen into such blatant immorality and foolishness, nevermind the pesky fact that this is the DIRECT RESULT of generational, intentional, systematic BRAINWASHING AND LIES AND PROPAGANDA AND WICKED CHANGES TO THE LEGAL CODES pushed on Americans by the very same forces who are leading the charge to have us request it!

Oh boy goody gosh golly!

I wonder if Jack Posobiec is a Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican... Just wondering out loud, plz don't attack me with downdoots I don't know if I'll survive that!!

permalink save report block reply

Welcome


The Great Awakening


We are researchers who deal in open-source information, reasoned argument, and dank memes. We do battle in the sphere of ideas and ideas only. We neither need nor condone the use of force in our work here. WE ARE THE PUBLIC FACE OF Q. OUR MISSION IS TO RED-PILL NORMIES.


WHY Q?

"Those who cannot understand that we cannot simply start arresting w/o first: ensuring the safety & well-being of the population shifting the narrative removing those in DC through resignation to ensure success defeating ISIS/MS13 to prevent fail-safes freezing assets to remove network-to-network abilities kill off COC to prevent top-down comms/org, etc. etc. should not be participating in discussions." Q


Welcome to the Digital Battlefield — Together We Win

Rules


Q Supporters

This is The Great Awakening. Our community is international, focused on helping ourselves and others walk away from the programming, and return our governments to "by the people, for the people!"



Follow the Law

No posts or comments that violate laws in your jurisdiction or the United States. The Feds are always watching!



No Bad Behavior!

No doxing, including revealing personal information of non-public figures, as well as addresses, phone numbers, etc. of public figures. All GAW users must adhere to the highest standards of conduct, whichever .WIN they are on. If we are notified by other moderators of incivil behavior on other .WINs, you WILL be banned here!



Civil Discussion ONLY**

They want you divided.

They want you labeled by race, religion, class, sex, etc.

Divided you are weak [no collective power].

Divided you attack each other and miss the true target [them].



No PAYtriots/No Self Promotion

Linking or promoting merchandise, fundraising, or spamming personal websites, blogs, or channels is not permitted. Do not attempt to profit from Q or advertise for those who do. Peace is the prize. We do it for free.



Questions and Concerns

All moderation questions and concerns should be submitted via modmail. DO NOT GRIEF the mods.



Expand your thinking

Remember, this .WIN is the public face of the Great Awakening, and, as a member here, you agree to represent the Great Awakening movement against Globalism, Communism and Progressive Insanity in the best, most positive way possible. NOTE: Your comments and posts may become news. Keep it classy!

This is not a 'fringe conspiracy' site: Visit https://conspiracies.win if that's your thing!



No doomers or shills

If you can't use common sense, you'll get banned without hesitation. If you're a shill, you fall under this rule. If you're a doomer, you fall under this rule as you just add garbage to the site like the other two. This includes forum sliding.



General Rules

  • Mods will issue NO warnings, followed by temporary bans and/or permanent bans. DO NOT GRIEF THE MODS.

  • Keep posts related to topics Q has raised or that are current.

  • Keep post duplication (especially from other .WINs) to a minimum.

  • HIGH EFFORT, HIGH-INFO posts only! Please respect other readers' time. Please use descriptive titles. No URLs in titles, pls. No clickbait.

  • No fame-fagging; no, "your" post did not get removed! Were you the original author?? Eyes on the prize, people!

  • Memes encouraged, but no low-quality, low-info posts.

  • Keep it honest and accurate.

  • GAW Supporters ONLY. (Sorry, the train had no brakes.)

  • Handshake noobs will be scrutinized by their Q knowledge, sincerity, and respect.

  • Remember, your conduct here represents the Q movement! OUR ENEMIES ARE WATCHING!

  • Please direct all complaints to modmail first!


Resources


WELCOME TO THE DIGITAL BATTLEFIELD


"River of Search" script:


GAW post formatting tips


Q Research (Q only posts at 8kun)


Q post archives (qagg.news) others 1 2 3 4


Browse Drops from the beginning


QProofs.com


Learn to read the Q map


Book of Q Proofs v1.3 (pdf)


Law of War & Majic Eyes Qnly Resources


Trumps twitter archive


POTUS: The Calm Before The Storm


Pedosta and DNC dumps


GIFs & QPosts


Poll Post Format


SPY ON US! See: mod Logs


The Greatest Show on Earth!


New to Q? "The Earth Chronicles Ep 12: Q & The White-Hat Op: What's Real, What's Not?"


Moderators

  • dropgun
  • catsfive
  • AutoMod
  • Filter
  • Fatality
  • Qanaut
  • bubble_bursts
  • Brent75
  • and 8 more...
Message the Moderators

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy

2026.02.01 - whmbz (status)

Copyright © 2026.

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy