someone is going to have to give up a piece of their pie so that someone else can have more."

Big Mike’s intention was probably to mean that the “someone else” should have more than he currently does, but the phrasing makes it seem like the “someone else” should have more than the original person does.

More importantly, notice the coercionist Big Mike’s casual use of the language of coercion: “going to have to give up”. The authority to make people have to give up property requires… authoritarianism. Big Mike’s quote is sugar-coated tyranny and theft.