It's worth reviewing, but I think until scientists and government are willing to release the underlying data, they won't find much public appetite for "scientific" analysis & summaries of said data.
The comments at the bottom get to the thrust of what is problematic.
One thing I remain grateful for is that neither vaccination nor viral raw-dogging it has proven to be an extinction level strategy.
Kirsch might actually have a shot at getting the data, see the study author's response in the comments:
"Nevertheless, any other person or structure, whether public or private, has the right to fully access the same SNDS data, upon official request to the French Health Data Hub (https://www.health-data-hub.fr/). Access to these data is not automatic and requires more than a simple request; it necessitates a scientifically sound protocol and proven expertise in data extraction and analysis."
It's worth reviewing, but I think until scientists and government are willing to release the underlying data, they won't find much public appetite for "scientific" analysis & summaries of said data.
The comments at the bottom get to the thrust of what is problematic.
One thing I remain grateful for is that neither vaccination nor viral raw-dogging it has proven to be an extinction level strategy.
Kirsch might actually have a shot at getting the data, see the study author's response in the comments:
"Nevertheless, any other person or structure, whether public or private, has the right to fully access the same SNDS data, upon official request to the French Health Data Hub (https://www.health-data-hub.fr/). Access to these data is not automatic and requires more than a simple request; it necessitates a scientifically sound protocol and proven expertise in data extraction and analysis."
References (1) https://drees.solidarites-sante.gouv.fr/publications-communique-de-presse/drees-methodes/les-taux-de-personnes-vaccinees-et-non-vaccinees (2) https://www.insee.fr/fr/accueil (3) https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/section_lc/LEGITEXT000006072665/LEGISCTA000033707709/#LEGISCTA000033708078