"What authority does POTUS have specifically over the Marines?" - #14 "Focus on the power of POTUS as it relates to the Marines." - #17 "Can the NG work in coordination w/ the marines? Do conditions need to be satisfied to authorize?" - #22
Code Federal Regulations - Title 32 National Defense - PART 631 - Subpart C: Off-Installation Operations (Military Patrols and Investigative Activities) and Policy These regulations deal with the military and how they assist with law enforcement. Some might say, BuT PosSe CoMiTatUs! Sure, let's look at 18 U.S. Code § 1385 - Use of Army and Air Force as posse comitatus. It's true that POTUS cannot use the Army or Air Force as posse comitatus without Congressional authorization.
HOWEVER, these restrictions do not apply to the usage of the Navy, and thus not to the usage of the Marines. Have a look at the Marine Corps Policy from the above CFR for details on how the Marines may be used "To assist Federal, State, and local law enforcement agencies within the limits imposed by higher authority and the Posse Comitatus Act," they remain "under the command of their Marine superiors when accompanying civilian police" and they "may come to the aid of civilian police in order to prevent the commission of a felony or injury to a civilian police officer." POTUS can use the Marines to help all non-military police forces to arrest traitors and insurrectionists and doesn't need any permission from Congress.
Yes, the Marines can work in coordination with the NG, and it's possible the NG has already been activated per the Insurrection Act. The conditions have been absolutely been met to justify POTUS using the NG and armed forces to enforce Federal authority. Granted, POTUS does not need any permission from Congress to use any regular military forces for defense against insurrection and rebellion. But those forces cannot be used to make arrests unless authorized by Congress. However, the Marines can make arrests under the authority of POTUS, without being barred by the Posse Comitatus Act. Arrests are the important aspect of this whole thing. Could regular civilian police make such a massive amount of arrests on their own? Are they reliable? Marines seem to be the better option, at least as support.
"What former President used the military to save the republic and what occurred exactly?" - #22
Washington used the military to put down the Whiskey Rebellion, but the more obvious answer would be Lincoln. Without his willingness to use the military to preserve the Union, the Republic may well have been forever sundered as a result of the Rebellion in 1860-1865. What happened? Rogue state officials (governors) and federal officials (Congressmen, judges etc) engaged in organized, mass insurrection and rebellion under illegitimate state "governments" to disregard the authority of the federal government. Sounds a bit similar to what occurred with the recent "elections" in certain states....
Many are assuming that IA was signed, I know I did. Don't forget that the recently signed Military Budget Bill included a provision that POTUS must ask for Congress permission to enact IA. But according to Wictor link/post earlier today (another thread) it was via FEMA and Miller to go around it. Many thought Trump was done when the (bill) veto was overriden, but I guess looking at the drops above this was already accounted for in the plan, years ago. OP maybe should amend the info and list Wictor's great insight into how Trump accomplishes what's required to use FEMA and Marines. And then maybe amend the OP and not mention the IA use?
Updated to clarify that it's possible but not confirmed that the IA was enacted and to clarify that POTUS doesn't need IA for federal regular forces, just NG. Do you have a link to the FEMA/Miller info?
Plan was probably already in place so Trump just let them they were in charge.
Got a link to the new Wictor??
Reported in another thread yesterday evening (PST) here, I see a few others picked up o this since, seems we now have multiple threads going:
Hokanson is answerable ONLY to Acting Secretary of Defense Chris Miller. That means army brass can't interfere. See why Trump never declared martial law or invoked the Insurrection Act? Now the people protecting him can't be called off except by Chris Miller. ** Its on Wictor's quodverum account, look about 14h ago (makes it ~11PM EST Jan. 14).**
It could have been a decoy too. Trump's good at that & at never giving out his real plan