Needs to go ultra mega viral ASAP🔺
(twitter.com)
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
Comments (44)
sorted by:
Without context to explain what we're seeing this is bullshit. Sorry. We have no idea what we're watching. We have no idea what they're saying. This could be a film production for all we know. We have no information about what this is. Who's the source? Where was it filmed? What is the author/presenter alleging we're seeing? How did he happen to come across the film? When was it taken?
AGREE 100%. Where is the BASIC context around this? I poured over the comments in the tweet and there was zero context rendered.
This scene has unfolded hundreds of thousands of times over the millennia. One of our most famous fairy tales, Hansel and Gretel first published in 1812, tells a similar tale.
History is our context.
It is hard to not be triggered and respond emotionally to this sort of content, but because of that, it's all the more important to apply critical thinking, which is what you are doing here.
Often this isn't the popular route, but in Information warfare, the information is the weapon, and needs to be handled responsibly, with discipline.
assuming something to be fake is just as bad as assuming it to be true. lets just admit we don't know
Actually, I kind of agree with you. I think the Moose really goes too far in saying "without context... .this is bullshit". To be honest, it doesn't look like bullshit to me at all.
However the questions the moose asks are good questions and relevant. It was really that aspect of the Moos's comment that I was addressing. It's not critical thinking to just say "without context .... its bullshit".
On the other hand, from the viewpoint of information sharing, one might say the sharing of the information is bullshit*, in that it may have no or even negative value, and cannot really advance the knowing of truth.
Admitting that we just don't know is a more balanced approach, but I also think that some aspects of the three different viewpoints expressed here actually have some merit.
no thanks, i would rather pursue truth honestly.
whether you know if something is true has no bearing on whether it is actually true.
no need to assume either way. use discernment.
Yeah, came here to say just that. Who, what, where, when... you know, the BASICS of news reporting.
Agree may as well be assumed propaganda