Noam Chomsky on Israeli “defense” narratives
(media.greatawakening.win)
Comments (43)
sorted by:
You know you're old when non-communists think they agree with Noam Chomsky.
Folks, this guy is notoriously far left. He's gone so far off the rails that he believes socialism without government can be a real thing.
Eh, even that has been under scrutiny. Read Tom Wolfe's The Kingdom of Speech.
I've actually made that point in the past, but even now I question it. They're all untalented globalist puppets in my mind.
Also Noam Chomsky
Yep, typical. In the Boomer through Gen X years, you could identify the Tavistock puppets by who was telling young people to reject authority. Those same puppets now tell us to never question authority. All phonies. Always were.
He believes the official 9/11 story
Well said.
This. All through out history civilizations have been displaced or moved when they lost wars or made foolish mistakes. I'm no making an argument for imperialism here, but this is how the world is.
So you support native Americans killing your family. After all, you are occupying their land.
Also, who was there before the Palestinians?
This logic is so fundamentally flawed.
That used to happen, but since that time a political solution was reached between both parties to achieve a peace with integration into wider society as a goal.
No the logic is sound, Your logic is fundamentally self serving imo.
I'm not picking a side. I'm just stating that it is not logical to assume that the prior tenants are the only ones with rights to a land. This would start a fruitless search that may end up with a group of people known for offering infants up as a sacrifice to a false god.
it isn't defense if you control your enemies power, water, food supply.
Chomsky is right on this, but having read much of his stuff in recent months I went from liking his work to seeing him as a rino/dino
Chomsky is so far left that he's utterly confused, which then confuses anyone reading his work.
noam chomsky is and always has been a cuck
rino??? Bro; chomsky is so far left, he might make marx himself blush.... Have you never heard of him?
Dude is an outright communist, in the fullest & truest sense of the word.
Yes that is the dino part and is uniparty
O, if the younger version of myself could only see that I'd be agreeing with Noam Chomsky in 20 years.
Hey Naom, we figured you out a long time ago… so go F yourself. Controlled oppo shill.
The land was Jewish for a thousand years before the Arabs learned to use toilet paper instead of their left hand. which is why even today the Arabs consider the left hand "dirty".
“A land without people, for a people without land”
Is a big lie. Propaganda.
Makes you wonder why they lie constantly
John 8:44 ?
I hate this guy. I hate him more when he says something I agree with.
give me a break. Israel has a legal right to exist as a state no matter how you slice. after the collapse of the ottoman empire there was a plan to give jews a state in their ancestral homeland. after world war 2, maybe due to sympathy from the holocaust, the plan got ratified by the rest of the world and moved forward. now some say the plans were supposed to include a palestinian state too, but after Israel was created the palestinians and surrounding arab nations attacked. in my opinion, this forfeits any plans of statehood they were previously offered. not only did Israel defeat the invaders, they conquered a swath of the middle east stretching almost to Cairo. so no matter how you ascribe ownership
the land belongs to israel. the only reason palestinians are still there is because no arab nation took them in or ever will, because having millions of hate-filled desert pirates who will suicide themselves at your command if you give them even some rocks to work with is a great asset.
“We”?
dont be pedantic. the noun that goes with it is perfectly clear
So you are israeli?
no, but you're clearly a dipshit
so who is “we”?
clearly its not you
Source?
i literally just listed the only 3 ways any country gets recognized, ever, in the history of the world. israel meets all 3. you have no argument, go away.
Sorry, but Israel isnt a legitimate country, and never will be. They are basically terrorists who steal land, ever since David Ben-Gurion made it clear that land theft was the plan.
that isnt an argument. your wishing their claim is illegitimate doesnt alter reality. i presented to you the only 3 claims anyone has to any land in all history and israel meets not 1 claim but all 3 claims. ancestral. treaty. and conquest. so go away.
Let's not forget, these are all our enemies, Hamas is same as ISIS remember Obummer the Muslem Brotherhood, Omar, Talieb ETC, Who are all of them for?
They are all Israeli-Mossad controlled opposition.
He also hammers on his opinion that israel is a proxy for the usa, never acknowledging the extraordinary israeli influence on u.s. government.
I mean, Heydrich was just defending himself from the Czechs when he got killed.
TIL
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinhard_Heydrich
This is like Russia saying it needs to defend itself from Ukraine in the land it seized from them.