The thread you responded to. Have you not read it? It starts with ...
If only we could be so lucky as to have Israel die with Iran
"Israel die with Iran".
What does that statement mean to you?
You think they're talking about the government of Iran? Can a government die?
Or do you think they're talking about all the people in Israel? Can all the people in Israel die?
I think you're being obtuse about it at this point. You've been here 6 years and you've never noticed people hating all Jews instead of the government of Israel and Mossad, really? I don't believe it.
You are a goalpost-moving weasel. Earlier you defined the Q quote of “saving Israel for last” as using “Israel” to refer to the government of Israel, which I’d probably agree with. Then you tried to define someone else’s quote of “If only we could be so lucky as to have Israel die with Iran” as using “Israel” to refer to every living jew. You should be more consistent and honorable than that. Of course the person could’ve been using figurative language of governments dying. As a litmus test, you could ask the quoted person if he desires the personal death of every living Iranian. You’re afraid to because you anticipate the person will answer “no, just the government”, and then you’d have to be consistent that “Israel” means their government just like “Iran” does, and you’d have to drop the neurotic jewish persecution complex schtick.
"Israel die with Iran". What does that statement mean to you?
Well in a vacuum it COULD mean what you're suggesting it means, but in the context of today's strategic attack on Iran's government, I'm not sure why you would assume the poster meant anything more than that.
When you asked the poster what he meant, what did he say?
You think they're talking about the government of Iran? Can a government die?
I think he's PROBABLY talking about the government of Iran. I see nothing in what he wrote that implies he wants every person in that country to die.
And yes, a government can die.
Or do you think they're talking about all the people in Israel? Can all the people in Israel die?
I don't think so, but I haven't asked them. Have you?
And yes, like a government (or the people within that government), all the people of Israel could theoretically die. What's your point?
I think you're being obtuse about it at this point. You've been here 6 years and you've never noticed people hating all Jews instead of the government of Israel and Mossad, really? I don't believe it.
I'll be honest, I've seen plenty of people hate on Jews here, but I never took that as them hating on ALL Jews. Regardless, I think the topic is a fair one, given their history. But maybe you just don't like people talking about that?
When I say "muh Joo", I'm talking about the group of Jew haters on GAW who hate every living Jew.
Israel (the government) and Mossad are targeted by Q, not every living Jew.
Ok. And could you point me to a few posters who say they hate every living Jew?
The thread you responded to. Have you not read it? It starts with ...
"Israel die with Iran".
What does that statement mean to you?
You think they're talking about the government of Iran? Can a government die?
Or do you think they're talking about all the people in Israel? Can all the people in Israel die?
I think you're being obtuse about it at this point. You've been here 6 years and you've never noticed people hating all Jews instead of the government of Israel and Mossad, really? I don't believe it.
You are a goalpost-moving weasel. Earlier you defined the Q quote of “saving Israel for last” as using “Israel” to refer to the government of Israel, which I’d probably agree with. Then you tried to define someone else’s quote of “If only we could be so lucky as to have Israel die with Iran” as using “Israel” to refer to every living jew. You should be more consistent and honorable than that. Of course the person could’ve been using figurative language of governments dying. As a litmus test, you could ask the quoted person if he desires the personal death of every living Iranian. You’re afraid to because you anticipate the person will answer “no, just the government”, and then you’d have to be consistent that “Israel” means their government just like “Iran” does, and you’d have to drop the neurotic jewish persecution complex schtick.
The downvote without rebuttal pulls the probability towards you being the downvoting stalker jew
Well in a vacuum it COULD mean what you're suggesting it means, but in the context of today's strategic attack on Iran's government, I'm not sure why you would assume the poster meant anything more than that.
When you asked the poster what he meant, what did he say?
I think he's PROBABLY talking about the government of Iran. I see nothing in what he wrote that implies he wants every person in that country to die.
And yes, a government can die.
I don't think so, but I haven't asked them. Have you?
And yes, like a government (or the people within that government), all the people of Israel could theoretically die. What's your point?
I'll be honest, I've seen plenty of people hate on Jews here, but I never took that as them hating on ALL Jews. Regardless, I think the topic is a fair one, given their history. But maybe you just don't like people talking about that?
That is a possibility. I'll concede your point and call myself wrong.