I am Protestant, baptized and raised, but I do not ever hear about Protestant pastors driving out demons in exorcisms. We know the spiritual world is real, so exorcisms have to be real by default. Demons can call out our sins to accuse us and drag us down with them, so that is also universal between Catholics and Protestants.
So what is the defining difference that gives Catholics the power to do the exorcisms and not Protestants?
Do they teach in a way that gives more divine authority? Are we doing something wrong? Or is it withholding information within the Catholic church?
One would never know that by their crimes against children. One doesn't need a church to worship God. Organized religion is a trap
On crimes against children, to be fair to all:
Direct comparison studies indicate that abuse rates among Catholic priests and Protestant ministers are comparable, falling within a similar 2–5% range, though data collection methods differ significantly between the two groups. The John Jay College of Criminal Justice report found that approximately 4% of Catholic priests were credibly accused of abuse between 1950 and 2002, while data from Christian Ministry Resources and insurance claims suggests Protestant clergy abuse rates are similarly 2–3% or roughly 260 claims per year across 165,500 churches.
Key findings from available research include:
Data Disparity: The Catholic Church has a centralized hierarchy that maintains meticulous records, leading to higher visibility and publicity of cases, whereas the decentralized nature of most Protestant denominations makes comprehensive data collection difficult and often results in underreporting.
Offender Demographics: Studies show that the majority of offenders in both Catholic and Protestant settings are male, typically middle-aged (around 40–60 years old), and often serve in mid-level positions like associate pastors or youth ministers.
Contextual Factors: While the absolute number of Catholic cases is high due to the Church's size, experts note that abuse is not unique to Catholic clergy; rates in Protestant churches are often driven by volunteers rather than ordained ministers, and some studies suggest Protestant congregations may have higher total allegations due to a larger number of volunteer youth leaders.
Group Estimated Offender Rate Data Source/Context Catholic Priests ~4.0% John Jay College Report (1950–2002) Protestant Clergy 2–3% Christian Ministry Resources / Insurance Claims K-12 Educators 5–7% Comparative institutional data General Male Pop. ~5% Comparative baseline
Experts emphasize that no formal comparative study has ever definitively proven that one denomination has a significantly higher incidence of abuse than the other, with the perception of a Catholic problem largely attributed to the Church's centralized record-keeping and the sheer scale of its global membership.
I so agree!!
That's what happens when you have homosexuals trying to suppress their sinfulness by going into the priesthood. No Catholic priests, homosexual or not, meets the biblical requirements for being a pastor or elder that's clearly laid-forth in scripture. It must be a married man with obedient children. The Catholic Church ignores this and the molestation problem is fruit of disobedience from God's word.
Well you certainly didn't test that with scripture did you?
That sentiment sounds rugged and independent, like a man declaring he doesn’t need a body because he’s quite fond of his head. It has a certain frontier charm, right up until you open the Bible.
Start with the obvious: Christ did not die to create a loose association of spiritual freelancers. He established a church. Not a vibe. Not a podcast. A real, visible people. In Matthew 16:18, He says He will build His church. Not suggest it. Not outsource it to your morning coffee devotion.
The apostle Paul, who was not known for ecclesiastical minimalism, says the church is the body of Christ in 1 Corinthians 12. If you don’t need the church, then apparently elbows and knees are optional now. Let me know how jogging goes with that arrangement.
And just to make sure no one tries the “just me and God” routine, we’re told plainly in Hebrews 10:25 not to neglect meeting together. The early Christians didn’t take that as a polite suggestion. They gathered, worshiped, received the Word, and submitted to leadership.
Which brings us to another uncomfortable point: Scripture actually commands believers to submit to elders in Hebrews 13:17. Hard to do that from your couch while declaring organized religion a trap. Unless your couch has recently been ordained.
Now, are there bad churches? Of course. There are bad marriages too, but that doesn’t mean you declare covenant life itself a scam and marry your houseplant. Abuse of a thing does not cancel its proper use.
The idea that “organized religion is a trap” usually ends with one man appointing himself pope of his own private universe. No accountability, no correction, no sacraments, no discipline. Just him, his Bible, and a suspiciously consistent agreement between the two.
Christians don’t gather because God needs attendance. We gather because we do. God has ordained the church as the ordinary means of grace, where the Word is preached, the sacraments are administered, and the saints are built up together.
So no, you don’t need a church the way a fish doesn’t need water. You can certainly try life without it. Just don’t be surprised when things start to smell off rather quickly.
You should absolutely be a part of a solid church but that's where the discernment kicks in. There are a lot of churches I wouldn't piss on if they were on fire.
The only trap you seem to have forgotten is the one where the wolves single out of sheep for slaughter away from the herd and shepherd.
I appreciate your perspective, although I find myself unable to align with your reasoning and the selective use of scripture to substantiate your viewpoint. If affiliation with an organized religion provides you with personal fulfillment, I commend that. As an individual who no longer actively participates in Catholicism, I personally did not derive satisfaction from attending Mass nor choose to join another denomination. No group think for me
Neither is necessary to meet with a congregation. Forget the building if need be, but don’t throw out the assembly.
Hebrews 10:25 in particular, as was pointed out - 24 Let us consider how to provoke one another to love and good works, 25 not forsaking our own assembling together, as the custom of some is, but exhorting one another; and so much the more, as you see the Day approaching.
I don’t believe in denominations myself, nor that “weekly sermon attendance” is necessary (though I do try to do so regularly), but the “good works” and “assembly” parts should not be neglected. We had a group who left our church to begin regular home-based worship/study.
One of the points of the crucifixion, imho, was the removal of the required central earthly authority.
Okay you said selective use of scripture to substantiate my viewpoint. But out of the two of us on the only one that actually used scripture. Would you like to provide some scripture that substantiates your own viewpoint? Then I'll respond. Because either God's word is the ultimate authority, or your own thoughts and feelings are.
You know who else doesn't think that God's word is the ultimate authority? The Catholic Church.
I don't fault you for having a bad experience with that organization that has deviated so far from and added so much to God's word and made their own standards.
However I believe that's led you to an over generalization fallacy. Not all churches or organizations are equal. That's like saying you won't fly an American flag because LGBT Q+ and Nazi flags exist so you're holding flags as a whole accountable.
At the end of the day God's word commands believers to be a part of the body of Christ. That is part of worshiping God. If you love God you will obey His commandments. Just as Jesus said that the Sabbath wasn't for God, it was for men, the same can be said for attending church. It's not so God can grow in himself, it's so you can be surrounded by other believers and grow.
I would encourage you to find a solid local, non-catholic Church and attend.
I understand that you've been burned before and your instinct is to avoid the kitchen entirely. Fair enough. But the answer is not starvation, it is finding a place that actually cooks real food.
Here's what I would suggest looking for:
📖 1. Scripture Is the Final Authority Preaching comes straight from the Bible, not opinions dressed in religious language The pastor explains the text in context, not cherry-picked slogans Look for steady teaching through books like Romans or Ephesians
✝️ 2. Christ-Centered, Not Institution-Centered Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection are the focus Salvation is taught as grace through faith, not earned performance No sense that the church itself is the gatekeeper of salvation
👥 3. Healthy Leadership (Plural and Accountable) More than one elder or leader, not a one-man show Leaders are approachable and accountable No celebrity-pastor culture
🧱 4. Clear Gospel, Not Guilt Manipulation Sin is taken seriously, but grace is bigger No pressure tactics, fear-based control, or spiritual intimidation Repentance is real, but not weaponized
🤝 5. Real Community (Not Just a Weekly Event) People actually know each other Opportunities for fellowship, service, and mutual care You are not just a seat-filler
🛐 6. Simple, Reverent Worship Focus on God, not production value Music and liturgy support truth, not emotional hype Ordinances like baptism and communion are practiced thoughtfully
⚖️ 7. Transparency and Integrity Financial clarity No secrecy around leadership decisions Willingness to answer hard questions without getting defensive
I truly appreciate your thoughtful response. I don't even know where to find a church that you describe😞 I live in Massachusetts. Our local Baptist church has rainbow flags and Black Lives Matter signs all over it. My state is completely corrupted
I'm with you, and praise be, I found my church after years of searching for, and commitment to, some real duds. I knew in the Spirit I had to keep looking.
Paul opens up Romans touching on how I feel about it:
1:11-12 11 I long to see you so that I may impart to you some spiritual gift to make you strong— 12 that is, that you and I may be mutually encouraged by each other’s faith.
Amen.
Apostasy is a big component of the illuminati. So, are they really priests or infiltrators? Apostasy happens across all the religions to destroy them.