A powerful scene in the Odyssey happens when Odysseus finally returns to Ithaca after twenty years of war and wandering.
You would expect the story to end with celebration, with the hero coming home, the family reunited, and order restored.
Homer does something far stranger.
Odysseus arrives disguised as a beggar, because Athena warns him that the palace has been taken over by more than a hundred suitors who have been living there for years, eating his food, drinking his wine, and pressuring his wife Penelope to marry one of them.
They believe Odysseus is dead and in their minds the kingdom is already theirs.
So the king of Ithaca walks through his own halls dressed in rags while the men stealing his house sit comfortably at his tables. They mock him, throw scraps at him, and one of them even strikes him, and Odysseus takes it. That is the remarkable part, because the same man who blinded the Cyclops and survived twenty years of disasters now stands quietly while strangers insult him in his own home. Homer tells us his heart burns inside his chest and that he wants to attack them immediately, yet he restrains himself and waits.
Instead of striking, Odysseus studies the room carefully. He counts the men, watches their habits, and quietly observes which servants remain loyal and which have betrayed him. The hero of the Odyssey does something most people cannot do, which is delay revenge until the moment is right.
Eventually Penelope announces a contest and brings out Odysseus’ great bow, declaring that she will marry the man who can string it and shoot an arrow through twelve axe heads lined up in a row. One by one the suitors try and fail, because none of them can even bend the bow. Then the beggar asks for a turn. The suitors laugh at first, but the bow is eventually handed to him.
Odysseus takes it in his hands and strings it effortlessly. Homer says the sound of the bowstring tightening rings through the hall like the note of a swallow. Then he places an arrow on the string and sends it cleanly through all twelve axe heads.
In that moment the beggar disappears. Odysseus turns the bow toward the suitors and reveals who he is.
What follows is one of the most brutal scenes in Greek literature. The doors are sealed and the suitors realize too late that they are trapped inside the hall. Odysseus, his son Telemachus, and two loyal servants begin killing them one by one. There is no escape, no mercy, and no negotiation. The men who spent years consuming another man’s house die inside it.
It is a violent ending, but Homer wants you to understand something important. The real danger to Odysseus was never just the monsters and storms on the long journey home. It was the possibility that someone else might take his place while he was gone. When Odysseus finally returns, he reminds everyone in Ithaca of a simple truth: a man’s home is not truly his unless he is willing to fight for it.
When I was in the Navy, stationed in Virginia there was a story released by the Navy of a SeAL Chief Warrant Officer who came back from deployment to find his wife in bed with another man. What he did reminds me of Odysseus' return. I don't remember what happened to the Gunner (that's what we call CWOs in the Navy), but I remember what he did because it sacred my ex wife so bad she never dared cheat on me while I was away.
Oh, and I hope we get to see a modern day telling of The Odysee that does Homer's story justice. It's one of my favorite Greek Epics.
Consider looking for the interlinear translation. It saves a lot of grief with "lost in translation" and willful distortions to place the story in Greece at a time when, as Thucydides in his book: History of the Peloponnesian War, remarks: There was no such a thing as Greece or Hellas, and certainly not a big thing as the Trojan War:
there was nothing on a great scale, either in war or in other matters
The story by Homer has a different origin. And especially the Odysee .... can be read on several levels, as a novel, as a map, as a spiritual journey.
Here is a story that will totally shake the " Homer's books are Greek stories" for two reasons:
Just because it is conveyed and retained in Greek does not mean it is originating from Greece. Thucydides already said so. It was a backwater, a colonial extraction area called JAVAN. Herodotus is the main culprit where it comes to misnaming. The great "geographer" was wrong on many accounts.
a. He name the river Hapi: The Nile. Which is wrong. Interestingly, the Pentateuch does not contain the word Nile, as the name of the river was a god: Hapi.
Menelaus is sailing in the area of Rhodus and is hit by a SOUTHERN STORM. Driven by the SOUTHERN STORM he ends up on the beach in Egypt.
Anyone with a map of the Med and a modicum of knowledge of sailing: this is impossible. It would be like: Being near Tallahassee, and ending up in Venezuela.
Some commentators lament that Homer was simply mistaken .....
This tells you, the story does not play out in the Med region at all.
Another tidbit that might spur some thought is the fact that Oera Linda Bok recounts the story of Frijes. think of Minerva as Mien erve = my inheritance. Athena does not mean anything in Greek. The story recounts how Athena was turned into a goddess.
Strabo mentions that in India, Punjab, they met Ger-mans ... or in the words of the OeraLinda Bok: Geertmannen. Several burgh have been established there among other: Wahallagara ....
History may be a bit different than is generally accepted.
I just bought this book last week for my homeschooler! Thanks Joy! I want to teach my son about loyalty and honor. Trump has both these qualities! What a job he has having to fight enemies on every front.
A powerful scene in the Odyssey happens when Odysseus finally returns to Ithaca after twenty years of war and wandering.
You would expect the story to end with celebration, with the hero coming home, the family reunited, and order restored.
Homer does something far stranger.
Odysseus arrives disguised as a beggar, because Athena warns him that the palace has been taken over by more than a hundred suitors who have been living there for years, eating his food, drinking his wine, and pressuring his wife Penelope to marry one of them.
They believe Odysseus is dead and in their minds the kingdom is already theirs.
So the king of Ithaca walks through his own halls dressed in rags while the men stealing his house sit comfortably at his tables. They mock him, throw scraps at him, and one of them even strikes him, and Odysseus takes it. That is the remarkable part, because the same man who blinded the Cyclops and survived twenty years of disasters now stands quietly while strangers insult him in his own home. Homer tells us his heart burns inside his chest and that he wants to attack them immediately, yet he restrains himself and waits.
Instead of striking, Odysseus studies the room carefully. He counts the men, watches their habits, and quietly observes which servants remain loyal and which have betrayed him. The hero of the Odyssey does something most people cannot do, which is delay revenge until the moment is right.
Eventually Penelope announces a contest and brings out Odysseus’ great bow, declaring that she will marry the man who can string it and shoot an arrow through twelve axe heads lined up in a row. One by one the suitors try and fail, because none of them can even bend the bow. Then the beggar asks for a turn. The suitors laugh at first, but the bow is eventually handed to him.
Odysseus takes it in his hands and strings it effortlessly. Homer says the sound of the bowstring tightening rings through the hall like the note of a swallow. Then he places an arrow on the string and sends it cleanly through all twelve axe heads.
In that moment the beggar disappears. Odysseus turns the bow toward the suitors and reveals who he is.
What follows is one of the most brutal scenes in Greek literature. The doors are sealed and the suitors realize too late that they are trapped inside the hall. Odysseus, his son Telemachus, and two loyal servants begin killing them one by one. There is no escape, no mercy, and no negotiation. The men who spent years consuming another man’s house die inside it.
It is a violent ending, but Homer wants you to understand something important. The real danger to Odysseus was never just the monsters and storms on the long journey home. It was the possibility that someone else might take his place while he was gone. When Odysseus finally returns, he reminds everyone in Ithaca of a simple truth: a man’s home is not truly his unless he is willing to fight for it.
An excellent story for times such as these.
Yes...
When I was in the Navy, stationed in Virginia there was a story released by the Navy of a SeAL Chief Warrant Officer who came back from deployment to find his wife in bed with another man. What he did reminds me of Odysseus' return. I don't remember what happened to the Gunner (that's what we call CWOs in the Navy), but I remember what he did because it sacred my ex wife so bad she never dared cheat on me while I was away.
Oh, and I hope we get to see a modern day telling of The Odysee that does Homer's story justice. It's one of my favorite Greek Epics.
I believe the story is an excellent allegory for our country, the infiltrators, and Trump's place as divine executor of justice.
The infiltrators have been eating our lunches and dismantling the house itself for far too long.
My thoughts exactly Mr A!
I can even imagine betrayal that the Gunner felt. She wasn't worthy of him. Praying he found a true mate.
Yes, it's a Classic!
...Saturday night culture corner...
...carry on Pilgrim...
...Saturday night culture corner...
...carry on Pilgrim...
Thanks pup! 🫡
... it's always good to remember the Classics..✨
Consider looking for the interlinear translation. It saves a lot of grief with "lost in translation" and willful distortions to place the story in Greece at a time when, as Thucydides in his book: History of the Peloponnesian War, remarks: There was no such a thing as Greece or Hellas, and certainly not a big thing as the Trojan War:
The story by Homer has a different origin. And especially the Odysee .... can be read on several levels, as a novel, as a map, as a spiritual journey.
Absolutely agree skipper..
can you say more on the matter? I've never heard the Odysse's origin being objected to
Yeah ... that is the regular normal thing.
Here is a story that will totally shake the " Homer's books are Greek stories" for two reasons:
Just because it is conveyed and retained in Greek does not mean it is originating from Greece. Thucydides already said so. It was a backwater, a colonial extraction area called JAVAN. Herodotus is the main culprit where it comes to misnaming. The great "geographer" was wrong on many accounts. a. He name the river Hapi: The Nile. Which is wrong. Interestingly, the Pentateuch does not contain the word Nile, as the name of the river was a god: Hapi.
Menelaus is sailing in the area of Rhodus and is hit by a SOUTHERN STORM. Driven by the SOUTHERN STORM he ends up on the beach in Egypt.
Anyone with a map of the Med and a modicum of knowledge of sailing: this is impossible. It would be like: Being near Tallahassee, and ending up in Venezuela.
Some commentators lament that Homer was simply mistaken .....
This tells you, the story does not play out in the Med region at all.
Another tidbit that might spur some thought is the fact that Oera Linda Bok recounts the story of Frijes. think of Minerva as Mien erve = my inheritance. Athena does not mean anything in Greek. The story recounts how Athena was turned into a goddess.
Strabo mentions that in India, Punjab, they met Ger-mans ... or in the words of the OeraLinda Bok: Geertmannen. Several burgh have been established there among other: Wahallagara ....
History may be a bit different than is generally accepted.
I just bought this book last week for my homeschooler! Thanks Joy! I want to teach my son about loyalty and honor. Trump has both these qualities! What a job he has having to fight enemies on every front.
Wow...bless you for homeschooling space! 👏
He invents pants?
You are cracking me up fren! Keklarious! 😹
kek
Love this post. Thanks J1D!
YW AB!
https://nitter.poast.org/i/status/2032411369786531841
Great ending, or Hmmm Great beginning 🤔
A Great Beginning!