"It is denied that the quoted provision currently applies to the 45th President of the United States since he is no longer "President". The constitutional provision requires that a person actually hold office to be impeached. Since the 45th President is no longer "President", the clause "shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for" is impossible..."

Yup. Since Trump signed the Insurrection Act... he is NOT President. Nobody is. The military is in control. Biden is NOT President, because under the insurrection act, that position is temporarily suspended. Biden couldn't be inaugurated to a position that was suspended at the time.

Heels Up Harris isn't Vice-President either.

:>) Trust the Plan.

Whatever happened to the impeachment article against Biden?

That appears to have gone quiet.

Right, and neither is Biden a valid sitting prez. Who has the football? The military.

He needs his day in court to produce the evidence of election fraud, and that it was members of Antifa who did the damage at the capitol. "Security" literally just let them in and members of Antifa are who did damage with patriots trying to stop them. This whole thing is a sham.

Why are you here? Serious question. Based on your post history, you don't seem very pro-Q, pro-Plan, or even Pro-POTUS

how could they argue he can't be impeached because he's out of office - if he was secretly maintaining office ?

This week's collective shill theme appears to be flood the forum with FUD by challenging everything and asking for proofs.

Undermining anything to provoke a response.

I can smell the hostile press, this week.

just saying

correct me if I am wrong, but, you can not impeach a President who is no longer the President, per the constitution?

Optics

Under the law Trump is no longer the President and Biden is. That doesn't mean that can't change but that is where we stand.

Nothing is going to happen until the Sham Impeachment trial takes place! Trump's hands are tied until that point.

Conversely, impeachment under the the Constitution is to remove an elected official from office. This is rather confirming he still is President.

Quotation marks always are a declaration. He is now the 19th Constitutional President and therefore outside the boundaries of anything created by the corporation and only to the Constitution.

Maybe it's different in legalese, but I kept seeing those as sarcastic quotes. Like "You all agreed, he isn't President any more."

Please learn how to read a legal document. This is Donald Trump's Answer (a form of pleading) to the Complaint (Impeachment). If you understand anything in law, an Answer is the Respondent's replay to the petition(s) made against him--and as noted so well by Trump's counsel--many complaints were set under one Impeachment, in an effort to gain a foothold by those who never want to see him in office). It seems Trump's counsel believes they placed so much into this impeachment that they plan to vote separately and thus gain, at some point, the percentage they need to keep Trump from seeking office again. Now that's the new American way of doing things, right? Screw the American people out of their Constitutional rights at every turn. Trump's counsel addresses each of the offenses he is alleged to have made. If you look closely, they agree that the impeachment document sets forth properly what the Constitution says.Trump and his counsel, though, deny that what those against him are doing is Constitutional, and they set forth his basis for that TRUTH. Trump's main argument is that he was not the president at the time the impeachment articles were presented to the Senate for a vote. TRUTH. And if he was not president at that time, he is a civilian: TRUTH. And as a civilian, he is not subject to impeachment: TRUTH. UNLESS MS. PELOSI THINKS SHE KNOWS SOMETHING NO ONE ELSE KNOWS--BUT REMEMBER--THESE PEOPLE ARE STUPID. Trump is not our president at this time. And that is the brilliance of all of this. Whether you choose to have hope that our military is, in fact, in charge of our nation (and we better be praying that is so) or whether Biden is truly in control (and if so, God help us all), Trump is not in office. He is a civilian. Either the military is in charge or Biden. Not Trump. He hasn't been our president since January 20 at--well, if we're to believe that we don't have to follow the Constitution--sometime before the Constitutional set time of 12:00 p.m., with Biden's hand on the Bible at 12:01. The inauguration happened before 12:00 and Biden's hand was not on the Bible--if that's what we want to call it--at 12:01 p.m. d all those who tried this treasonous action against him will pay. Can that be made any clearer? Probably so. I'm s clear as mud sometimes. So, feel free to clarify or correct. I have a legal background, but I'm not a Constitutional scholar. However, I think it should be the duty of every American citizen to study the Constitution and know it inside out. Our lack of knowledge is what has allowed the Democrats and Faux Republicans to screw us for years and to lead us up to this point where we truly believe we are a democracy slipping past socialism and hading into communism. America is a Constitutional Republic, and I pray to God that Trump is still fighting for us in his role as a civilian until we can reinstate him as the true president and hang the Chinese puppet.

Is this something that could possibly end up going to the Supreme Court?